Founder-led design puts the person who knows the product best - its founder - in charge of the creative process. This approach ensures designs align with the company’s core vision, respond quickly to feedback, and are tailored to user needs. On the other hand, large agencies rely on standardized processes that, while polished, may dilute a brand’s identity and slow down decision-making.

Key Takeaways:

• Founder-led design: Offers vision alignment, faster decision-making, and user-focused solutions. However, it can be challenging if the founder lacks design expertise or is stretched thin.

• Big agencies: Provide polished results and handle complex projects well but often struggle with personalization, speed, and cost efficiency.

Quick Comparison:

Conclusion: For startups, founder-led design ensures a stronger connection to the product and faster results. Agencies may be better suited for larger, more complex projects, but they come at a higher cost and risk losing the personal touch.

Founder Fridays: Most founders get design wrong with Brian Lovin, Campsite & Anastasia Crew, Notion

1. Founder-Led Design

When founders take charge of design, they bring something special to the table: complete control over their vision. Their hands-on approach often results in a process that feels genuine and deeply connected to the purpose of the product.

Vision Alignment

Founders infuse their passion and vision into every design decision. This ensures that the design stays true to the company’s core values while sharing a story that resonates with users on a personal level.

Agility

With a clear vision in place, founder-led design thrives on agility. Without the bureaucracy of multiple approval layers, founders can quickly adapt designs based on user feedback or changing market conditions. Their intimate knowledge of the business allows them to make quick decisions, balancing features, aesthetics, and functionality in a way that keeps the process efficient and focused.

Personalization

Thanks to their deep understanding of the product, founders are uniquely positioned to create designs that directly address user needs. Their involvement fosters a personal connection between the brand and its users, making the experience feel more authentic and relatable. By combining their knowledge of the audience and the product, they ensure that design solutions truly tackle real-world challenges.

This combination of vision, adaptability, and user-focused design sets founder-led design apart from the more structured approaches often seen in large agencies.

2. Big Agencies

Big design agencies bring a wealth of resources to the table, but their size often comes at the expense of a personal touch. Let’s break down how their approach to vision alignment, agility, cost, and personalization shapes their strengths and limitations.

Vision Alignment

With a roster packed full of clients, big agencies often create designs that blend various influences. The result? Outputs that might look polished but don’t always reflect the unique vision or identity of a specific company.

Agility

Large agencies tend to operate on structured timelines with multiple layers of review. While this ensures consistency, it also slows down the process. If your market shifts or you need quick updates, navigating through their approval process can feel like steering a cruise ship - it’s anything but fast.

Cost

Working with a big agency means paying for more than just the design work. Overhead expenses like office space and management salaries are baked into their pricing. And if your project scope changes? Expect a formal change process that could stretch both your budget and your timeline.

Personalization

To reduce risks, big agencies often lean on standardized templates. While these can result in professional-looking designs, they may lack the distinctiveness that truly aligns with your brand. On top of that, once the project wraps up, the reasoning behind key design choices isn’t always passed along, leaving future iterations disconnected from the original strategy.

Pros and Cons

Let’s dive into the strengths and weaknesses of each approach.

Founder-led design shines when you want designs that perfectly align with your vision and cater directly to your users' needs. Founders often have a deep understanding of their product, resulting in solutions that feel purposeful and genuine. However, this approach can hit roadblocks if the founder lacks design expertise or becomes too stretched with other responsibilities.

Big agencies, on the other hand, bring a polished touch and well-established processes. Their experienced teams consistently deliver high-quality work, but their standardized methods might not fully capture your brand's unique identity. Plus, their services often come with a heftier price tag compared to the more adaptable, founder-led model.

These distinctions highlight the key differences. For instance, options like Exalt Studio's retainer model provide startups with ongoing design support starting at $4,000 per month. This setup allows startups to access responsive, continuous service without requiring a massive upfront investment.

Timing is another critical factor. For early-stage startups, founder-led design is ideal for quick iterations and ensuring the product stays true to the original vision. Conversely, more mature companies may benefit from the specialized expertise and resources that large agencies offer. However, each path comes with challenges: founders need to develop their design skills and stay updated on UX trends, while agencies might sideline founders during the creative process. When it comes to scaling, founder-led design may struggle to manage multiple projects at once, whereas big agencies excel at handling complex, multi-layered initiatives across multiple product lines.

Conclusion

Founder-led design can be a game-changer for startups and SaaS companies. When the person who knows the vision, users, and market best is at the helm of design decisions, the results often align seamlessly with the company’s mission.

This approach brings several benefits: direct alignment with your vision, quicker iterations, and solutions that feel custom-made for your product. While large agencies might deliver polished work, their standardized processes and layers of approvals can sometimes slow things down or fail to fully capture your brand’s voice. Founder-led design, on the other hand, gives startups the agility and authenticity they need to stand out.

For startup founders and SaaS leaders, sharpening design intuition through user research, ongoing feedback, and strong design principles is key. Flexible models, like Exalt Studio's retainer service, can provide continuous design support while keeping you deeply involved in the creative process.

The contrast between founder-led design and big agency methods is clear. Early-stage companies thrive with a hands-on approach, while scaling up might require bringing in external expertise - without losing control over the creative direction.

FAQs

How can a founder without a design background successfully lead the design process?

A founder doesn’t need a design background to guide the design process effectively. What matters most is leveraging your strengths. Start by clearly outlining your vision, business objectives, and deep understanding of your target audience. This sets the foundation for your design team to translate those ideas into tangible results.

Work closely with skilled designers, giving them the freedom to execute while staying involved in major decisions. Focus on clarity and collaboration, ensuring your input guides the process without veering into micromanagement. Regularly seek feedback from both stakeholders and users to fine-tune the design and keep it aligned with your broader goals. Your product expertise and active involvement can lead to designs that feel thoughtful and resonate with your audience.

How can companies keep their designs personalized while scaling up?

To keep personalization at the heart of your business as it expands, start by focusing on truly understanding your audience. Dive deep into their preferences, behaviors, and needs, and ensure your design choices reflect what matters most to them. Using tools that combine customer data and offer real-time insights can help you craft experiences that feel relevant and tailored, even as your customer base grows.

Another key strategy is building cross-functional teams that emphasize flexibility and collaboration. These teams can adapt quickly to changing demands while maintaining a customer-first approach. Incorporating AI and automation into your processes can also make scaling easier, helping you manage growth without losing the personal touch that sets your brand apart. By staying customer-focused and intentional with your designs, you can maintain authenticity and align with your brand's vision as you grow.

Is founder-led design more cost-effective than hiring a big agency in the long run?

When it comes to cost-effectiveness, founder-led design often stands out in the long run. Large agencies typically charge steep fees - anywhere from $150 to $300 per hour or even up to $150,000 per project. In contrast, founders bring an edge that’s hard to replicate: their in-depth knowledge of both the product and its audience. This reduces the need for pricey external input.

On top of that, founder-led design thrives on genuine connection and flexibility, aligning closely with business objectives and delivering a stronger return on investment (ROI). By prioritizing this tailored approach, businesses often see more sustainable growth compared to the cookie-cutter strategies employed by many big agencies.

Related Blog Posts

• Why Founder-Led Design Is the Secret Weapon for High-Growth SaaS Startups